Document Type
Doctoral Dissertation
Degree Name
Doctor of Philosophy in Leadership with a specialization in Sports
Publication Date
5-2025
Granting Institution
Concordia University-Chicago
Committee Members
Dr. William Spears, Ph.D., Dissertation Chair Dr. Alison Clark, Ph.D., Methodologist Dr. Sandra Svoboda, Ph.D., Reader
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to investigate the role of physical play, more specifically fighting and hitting, in professional hockey, exploring the impact on gameplay, team dynamics, and success. Despite the significant rule changes within the National Hockey League (NHL) which focused on minimizing fighting, the strategic use of fighting and hitting remains a highly debated aspect of the sport. The study applies a basic qualitative research approach, gathering data through interviews, questionnaires, and game observations with current and former NHL, AHL, ECHL, players, coaches, referees, and analysts. Findings indicate that physical play, particularly hitting and fighting can positively impact game momentum, psychological play, and intimidate opponents as well at times help teams win games. Excessive reliance on fighting and hitting does not correlate with long-term success, but if used strategically, it can contribute to success over time. This study contributes to the ongoing discussion on player safety, changing strategies in team dynamics, and potential future policy directions for the NHL to balance tradition with modern gameplay demands.
Rights
Copyright © by Samuel Vogel-Seidenberg, 2025 All rights reserved.
